Comments on: Child Welfare in Travel: 10 Do’s and Don’ts for Engaging Responsibly https://uncorneredmarket.com/child-welfare-in-travel-tips/ Travel That Cares for Our Planet and Its People Sat, 28 Jan 2023 16:24:50 +0000 hourly 1 By: Audrey Scott https://uncorneredmarket.com/child-welfare-in-travel-tips/#comment-1510200 Sun, 24 Feb 2019 20:32:18 +0000 https://uncorneredmarket.com/?p=30442#comment-1510200 In reply to indiabiro.

Thanks for sharing your story. Often, our gut is right in situations like this — if something doesn’t “feel” right then there’s probably a reason for this. It is quite sad that situations like this are so common, but we agree that not contributing to try and break this cycle is the best option.

]]>
By: indiabiro https://uncorneredmarket.com/child-welfare-in-travel-tips/#comment-1507313 Thu, 24 Jan 2019 19:07:52 +0000 https://uncorneredmarket.com/?p=30442#comment-1507313 This reminds me of an encounter I had in San Antonio Palopó on the shores of Lake Atitlán in Guatemala ca. 3 years ago. I was 19 years old and it was my first ever trip outside of Europe. I was sitting on a bench overlooking the shore when this little hand tapped me on the shoulder, and when I turned around, it was a very small Mayan girl in the village’s typical blue dress. She stretched her hand out and said “Un quetzal. La foto”. It took me a while to realize she was asking me to take a picture of her and then give her 1 quetzal (~ 10 cents). I told her, in my best Spanish, that I could not do that because she was a child and she should be in school, and where are her parents? She just stared at me blankly, and then repeated “la foto”. It was then that I realized she couldn’t even speak Spanish yet, but she was already out and about asking tourists for money. I seriously hope she’s okay and not in any danger (as well as her even younger sister, who was watching us), and even though she was incredibly cute I am so glad I did not take that photo because it did not feel like the right thing to do.

]]>
By: Audrey Scott https://uncorneredmarket.com/child-welfare-in-travel-tips/#comment-1503017 Sun, 16 Dec 2018 15:33:38 +0000 https://uncorneredmarket.com/?p=30442#comment-1503017 In reply to Kristin Pedemonti.

Kristin, thank you for your comment and sharing your story and experiences from your work in Belize. This has been an evolution in awareness and understanding better the possibilities of unintended harm even when the intentions of the traveler/visitor is good and truly wants to help. But, as you said, there are often so many things at work locally that can affect whether something does harm or causes side problems that you had never imagined. That’s why it’s so important, as you said, to always be asking yourself the question “Can this action/project/behavior cause harm in some way?” and to earn the trust of local people who can advise you on socio-economic and cultural considerations.

]]>
By: Audrey Scott https://uncorneredmarket.com/child-welfare-in-travel-tips/#comment-1503009 Sun, 16 Dec 2018 14:59:46 +0000 https://uncorneredmarket.com/?p=30442#comment-1503009 In reply to Alyssa Forney.

Alyssa, thank you for your long and thoughtful comment. I’m glad you found this article useful and provided some additional information to what you’ve already researched and written about regarding trafficking and the tourism industry. Although we’ve always been concerned about doing the “right” thing when it comes to local children and child welfare, we began going more deeply into researching these issues a few years ago after traveling in East Africa and Haiti. We not only talked with local people about what we saw and what the best thing travelers should do, but we also began reaching out to experts to learn more about the issue. It’s been a journey of increased awareness. And, we’re still learning and asking questions.

]]>
By: Janice https://uncorneredmarket.com/child-welfare-in-travel-tips/#comment-1502250 Sun, 09 Dec 2018 06:00:17 +0000 https://uncorneredmarket.com/?p=30442#comment-1502250 While I agree that we should never give to child beggars or to support children selling things during school hours, I have a different perspective from a friend I have in Central America. In rural Guatemala, good education isn’t free. The government schools have few supplies and often poorly trained teachers. There are very few public secondary schools. My friend, who is now a successful businessman and also runs a foundation to promote and support education, started working at age 10 – to pay for his schooling. Its life in a lot of the world that as soon as children are old enough to contribute to the family’s survival they do. By not supporting a child trying to earn a few cents for school supplies or tuition, you may be contributing to the child dropping out of school. As a person privileged to live in a first world country, I do support causes that make education more readily available to all children but in the meantime, I’ll help a single child make a little money – as long as it doesn’t interfere with his education.

]]>
By: Kristin Pedemonti https://uncorneredmarket.com/child-welfare-in-travel-tips/#comment-1500112 Wed, 21 Nov 2018 17:55:24 +0000 https://uncorneredmarket.com/?p=30442#comment-1500112 Thank you for publishing such a comprehensive list of Don’ts and alternatives that are more positive in impact. I’ve always appreciated how mindful you and Dan both are and how you share your learning with us! It is always important to ask ourselves: “will this do any harm?”

These same questions and Don’ts you list are really important in projects/programs too. So much damage done when the program creators don’t ask, “will this cause unintended harm?”

I constantly ask myself this. And it started in 2005 when I founded and facilitated literacy outreach in Belize, upon an invitation from a local.

2005-2012 My own school visits were not to take photos but to teach and train local teachers w/ developing the curriculum w/ support from the local administration, in-country literacy programs and university ed programs. Yet I always asked myself, “Am I unintentionally doing harm?” What if my literacy program which used local cultural stories (told to me and used with permission) somehow created friction in local families because I was telling girls it was good for them to be in school? What if their parents disagreed, would that child then be beaten or harmed because I said the opposite? Whew!

It’s a fine line and one we really need to fully consider BEFORE we do anything in another country/culture. Be sure you understand and ask what is needed too. I did 6 months of in-country research and asking locals what would best serve while creating the program to do my best to do no harm. And I still questioned what I was offering.

So yes, please, even with programs, let’s look at the bigger picture and each ask ourselves: “am I doing any harm?”

As for buying from kids thank you for highlighting the deep damage caused! So many layers.

I went to one orphanage in 2006 and shortly afterwards was educated of the damage that can cause. I’ve done my best to talk so many others out of going: what seems like like being loving and harmless not only leads to what you described it is also psychologically damaging to the actual orphans: it re-opens abandonment issues among others.

Thank you again Audrey for how mindful you and Dan always seek to be and for admitting your own learning curve. I love that about you both!

Big hugs and thank you for sharing a really important and needed list of tips!
Kristin

]]>
By: Alyssa Forney https://uncorneredmarket.com/child-welfare-in-travel-tips/#comment-1499906 Tue, 20 Nov 2018 08:44:12 +0000 https://uncorneredmarket.com/?p=30442#comment-1499906 Hello! I really appreciated all that this article brought to life for the every day traveller. While many people may think they are doing good while traveling, such as advocating for sustainable energy, education for girls, or raising money or awareness, many times the small practices are not thought about. I never would have thought about the whole outcome that giving money or candy to a child beggar could result in the parent of the child keeping the child from school if they earn more money on the street. That thought was really shocking to me! I have written a blog post on the dangers of human trafficking and tourism but your article touched on aspects of the issue I never thought or even read about during my research. Taking pictures of children and tagging their location makes them more vulnerable to human trafficking. It is so important for everyone to educate themselves on these possibilities and your blog does a great job at explaining why!

]]>